BBC Newsnight producer takes stand favoring P2P

Marshall Kirkpatrick — 2006-03-01T14:44:00+00:00

It's often said that "legitimate" voices are an important part of moving the discussion on P2P and filesharing away from the rhetoric of crime. BBC Newsnight Producer Adam Livingstone has thrown his two cents into the mix, saying that filesharing isn't theft and that there are ulterior motives behind some of the players in the debate.

Most interesting to me is his assertion that ISPs are willing to block P2P traffic not just because they are in bed with the Hollywood cabal but also because they don't know how to deal with the huge traffic that P2P brings to their networks. They are engaged in what he calls traffic shaping.

It's terrible that emerging technologies are being mitigated and criminalized all together because some people engage in arguably anti-social uses and the old-school service providers don't care to catch up with the market's needs. Even if you think that much of file sharing is theft, is it worth the cost to innovation to shut down the mechanisms of file sharing entirely? Remember the argument that pr0n moves technologies forward that are later leveraged for more productive use? Imagine if things like home video were shut down using any of the above logic.

Permalink | Email this | Linking Blogs | Comments

Sponsored by: Userplane Apps: Live communication applications powering the world's leading online communities.

The Social Software Weblog

BBC Newsnight producer takes stand favoring P2P