
Readers here have probably come across the
new service
coComment, a means of tracking the comments you leave around
various blogs. The buzz on this one is huge. What are people saying?
- Scalability. The folks at coComment are getting slammed and though they say more servers are on the way, scalabilty is always an
issue for Web 2.0 applications, isn't it?
- Greasemonkey. If you're a Firefox and Greasemonkey user,
the bookmarklet to track a comment can now be automated so you don't have to remember to click each time you post your
thoughts online. Brian Benzinger put
one script together and got lots of discussion of his review of the system.
- Platforms. The
system works with most of the major blogging systems, but not all. Movable Type was just added today. Drupal is rumored to not work
at all.
- Navel gazing. The funny folks at MoBuzz.TV
video blog seem to be of the belief that only an ego maniac with delusions of grandeur would be excited about this
service. If that's the case then the web is full of ego maniac's with delusions of grandeur. Maybe we
already knew that, but I'm not so sure they're right. So who's got a story about something really useful coming
from being able to track your comments or the comments of some one else? Really, this is serious - or is
it?
- The walled garden of conversation. coComment currently tracks comments left in response to
yours, but so far only those left by other coComment users. Who cares what newbies have to say anyway? No,
to be fair I'm sure this is a technical matter - but it sure would be nice to see it overcome.
- Alternatives and Identity. There's a nice conversation over at Bright Meadow on a Spanish alternative called
MyCo and several ideas of how a system like this could be integrated into larger efforts around Identity and Attention
data. No mention of any of this yet over on the Attention Trust
blog.
I personally will probably continue using this system. I do think it is one of several small
service features that ought to be included in an Attention/Identity suite offered by a benevolent organization like the
Attention Trust. It seems useful
enough, basic enough and unlikely enough to ever be too interoperable with other systems that I'd worry about putting
all my eggs in one new little basket. I noticed that searches of the coComment company blog for XML and
"export" came up with nothing...so I do worry about my info being locked in. You could say that better to be
locked in to one vendor than to never have easy access to the info at all - but I think the web can do better than
that. I won't be posting a list of my comments elsewhere on my blog, unless I see something more useful than
egotism resulting from other folks doing that.
1. Do registered users recieve invitetions which they can send to their friends?
If u have a spare invitation send me one pls.
i'm also excited about the idea of the service and wanna to use it ASAP.
Posted at 6:48PM on Feb 9th 2006 by maxon